If Davis Gates had simply defended her family’s decision by saying something like her son really had his heart set on going to that school, then I don’t think anyone could really disagree with her choice.
Instead, the union president initially stonewalled when faced with questions and then offered up an explanation to a local public radio station which threw the South and West sides under the bus and, more importantly, just wasn’t true.
Davis Gates said basically three things last week to a WBEZ reporter: 1) Course offerings for high schools on the South Side and West Side “are very marginal and limited”; 2) Selective enrollment and magnet public high schools were just too far away and would’ve forced her son to, according to the article, “spend hours traveling”; 3) A public high school with a good soccer program (a sport played by her son) and strong extracurriculars are just not available close by, or are in Latino neighborhoods that were too far away.
Look, there’s no doubt whatsoever that problems exist in public schools on the South and West sides. But that doesn’t mean the areas are completely bereft, no matter what internet trolls scream online.
Just as a small sampling, Davis Gates lives only three miles from Gwendolyn Brooks College Prep, a high quality selective enrollment high school which has a soccer team and extracurricular activities.
Lindblom Math and Science Academy in the West Englewood neighborhood has a pretty darned good soccer team and is 6 miles from the union president’s home.
The Catholic school her son is attending, on the other hand, is almost 9 miles from Davis Gates’ home.
Not to mention the area’s charter schools, which are taxpayer-funded and privately operated.
Past Elections
Current Temperature
Monday, September 11, 2023
Rich Miller: Davis Gates’ explanation doesn’t hold up
Wednesday, September 6, 2023
CapFax: CTU president won’t answer questions about enrolling her son in private prep school
Let me enter a quote before we link to Capitol Fax
To me, the Chicago Magazine quote, “I can’t advocate on behalf of public education and the children of this city and educators in this city without it taking root in my own household” really leaves her open to this.
Tuesday, August 22, 2023
CapFax: MAA grills the mayor on the CTU, CPD and Arwady
NBC Chicago's Mary Ann Ahern speaks with Mayor Johnson and when you click through to the Capitol Fax blog be prepared for the evasive answers.
MAA grills the mayor on the CTU, CPD and Arwady https://t.co/5Y493Eyegf
— Capitol Fax (@capitolfax) August 22, 2023
Monday, February 8, 2021
Terms for Chicago Teachers to return to the classroom
If you were concerned about the negotiations between the city and the teacher's union as far as opening public schools back up, here's a post about it from Rich Miller. Gives you a basic idea of what these negotiations are about.
Question of the day https://t.co/Cl8WgNGWB9
— Rich Miller (@capitolfax) February 8, 2021
Saturday, January 23, 2021
CPS: All instruction could be halted if teacher's don't return to work
For those of you concerned about the back and forth between the city and the teacher's union. The union doesn't want teachers to go back to in-person instruction at the schools. If CPS teachers don't return to school all instruction including virtual instruction could come to a halt.
From the Sun-Times
If Chicago teachers collectively refuse to return to their schools on Monday in defiance of Chicago Public Schools’ reopening orders, the district will consider the labor action a strike, schools chief Janice Jackson reiterated Friday, suggesting the outcome could be all classes coming to a halt.
The 25,000 rank-and-file members of the Chicago Teachers Union are voting through Saturday night on a resolution to continue working from home next week because of health concerns tied to in-person work.
CPS officials have said working from home is no longer an option for about 10,000 educators who have been told to report in person, nor for the 3,800 who have been ordered to schools since early January.
The union has repeatedly argued its action Monday would not be a work stoppage since teachers plan to continue working remotely. The CTU’s pending resolution instead says a strike would start if CPS “retaliates” by locking out all its teachers from remote work as it has done with about 90 pre-Kindergarten and special education staff members who were supposed to report to their schools earlier this month but haven’t shown up.
Friday, December 18, 2020
College Fix: Chicago Teachers Union demands public schools stay closed as Catholic schools in city have safely remained open
The Chicago Teachers Union recently asked a judge to issue an injunction ordering Chicago Public Schools to remain closed to in-person learning for the spring semester. It comes as the city public school system plans to return K-8 students in January and February, according to its reopening plans.
Catholic schools in the city and surrounding area have been open for a hybrid model of in-person and remote learning for a full semester now, with minimal problems. As private entities, Catholic schools have been allowed to stay open under health guidelines, while public schools have been fully remote for the fall semester.
I wonder how many of you are ready to send your children back to school soon.
h/t Newsalert
Thursday, June 18, 2020
CapFax: CTU slammed for “clearly racist” tweet
Y’all too much sometimes. 😂😂💀#DefundthePolice #PoliceFreeSchools #CopsOutCPS (IG: @electricstripe) pic.twitter.com/I4ryy3vOvM— ChicagoTeachersUnion (@CTULocal1) June 18, 2020
Rich Miller further notes: "According to Chalkbeat, more than half of Chicago public school teachers are white. The CTU’s president is a wealthy white man."
Bad optics on all fronts. I get that the CTU and Mayor Lightfoot had been at odds since the strike late last year. However, this seems very incendiary. Further more I'm glad the mayor had a response to this noting what the response would've been if a right wing group had put this out. The condemnation should be no less if it was police, right-wingers, or even the teachers.
Mayor Lori Lightfoot blasts this tweet: “If that kind of tweet, which is clearly racist, had been put forward by a right-wing group, we would rightly be denouncing them. I think our scorn should be no less because it was put out by the CTU." https://t.co/VLYlwkwrXl— Gregory Pratt (@royalpratt) June 18, 2020
Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Decline in Black teachers?
Thursday, January 16, 2020
CapFax: More of this, please
More of this, please https://t.co/URqKUP5m5Y— Rich Miller (@capitolfax) January 16, 2020
Wednesday, October 30, 2019
Springfield's response to the Chicago teacher's strike #twill
Madigan defers consideration of CTU-backed bills until spring session https://t.co/fOlMBzNKzM— Rich Miller (@capitolfax) October 30, 2019
Meanwhile today marks 10 days out of school for CPS students.
Monday, October 28, 2019
Capitol Fax: Must-see CPS strike videos
Must-see CPS strike videos https://t.co/T1IP3tuIXz— Rich Miller (@capitolfax) October 25, 2019
Friday, October 25, 2019
Chicago Teacher's strike updates
This first item from earlier this week involved the negotiations between the Mayor and the teachers. Funny thing about this is the notion that if you want to frustrate the process just bring more people to the table. Main thing is there is a real strategy to doing so if you know the other side has something to lose in this.
Pick a lane, please https://t.co/dUIUxtQn1C— Rich Miller (@capitolfax) October 22, 2019
Pressure intensifies on both sides as legislators stand with CTU https://t.co/bW3ySccRUx— Rich Miller (@capitolfax) October 24, 2019
Finally here are a couple of Instagram posts shared on Thursday from CPS with regards to their teachers union offer.
Monday, October 21, 2019
No resolution to the teacher's strike yet...
CTU to Lightfoot: Nope https://t.co/Ahlx0zDSOw— Rich Miller (@capitolfax) October 21, 2019
Saturday, October 19, 2019
Teacher's strike started on Thursday
I want to share these two recent posts from CapFax regarding the strike. The first is more of a round-up.
CTU strike bits and pieces https://t.co/HDDyrkpjIj— Rich Miller (@capitolfax) October 18, 2019
Unsolicited advice https://t.co/SMDUOO48F3— Rich Miller (@capitolfax) October 17, 2019
Tuesday, October 15, 2019
Teacher's strike: Small number of Chicago voters oppose strike
Poll: Just 38 percent of Chicago voters oppose CTU strike https://t.co/A14GZCDUq4— Rich Miller (@capitolfax) October 15, 2019
Saturday, October 12, 2019
Tribune: Mayor says CTU ‘refusing to negotiate in good faith;' union calls city offer ‘half-baked’
Thursday, October 10, 2019
WTTW: What’s Next in Lead-Up to a Chicago Teachers Strike?
The Chicago Teachers Union has set a strike date of Oct. 17, but the deadline for the city to come to a deal with the 25,000-member union may be sooner.Very interesting. I still hope there will be no strike.
This year, the union’s 700-member House of Delegates – which represents teachers across the city – passed a resolution requiring CTU leadership to bring any tentative deals back to an emergency meeting of those delegates. Those members would then decide whether to call off a strike.
Theoretically, this means even if a contract deal is reached at the 11th hour, teachers could be on the picket lines Oct. 17, and remain there until delegates have reviewed the contract and decided whether to accept the city’s offer.
Sources in CTU say members were angered when, in 2016, union leadership called off a strike after reaching a deal right around the midnight deadline. Some teachers woke up and went to the classroom – instead of the picket line – without knowing the terms of the deal; others were angered at the content of the deal and the fact that CTU had called off the strike without their input.
Wednesday, October 9, 2019
Chicago's teachers: What are the issues?
Monday, October 7, 2019
Before the strike news...
Meanwhile as negotiations more forward ahead of the set October 17th deadline according to the Tribune:
The CTU has set an Oct. 17 deadline for CPS and teachers to reach a deal on a new contract. If not, they can go on strike, disrupting the school year for thousands of public school pupils across the city.
Lightfoot said she wants to reach an agreement that would prevent that from happening, but she’s concerned that the city has not received a detailed formal response to its proposal.
“We can’t bargain against ourselves,” Lightfoot said. “We need to have them at the table with a comprehensive counteroffer. … If we do that we can get there.”
The teachers union fired back on Twitter, saying: “We were showing urgency about a fair contract before the mayor was mayor. City Hall and CPS didn’t show urgency until 94% of our membership voted to strike.”